Imagine setting out on a road trip. Would you trust a car brand with no track record, or would you choose one known for reliability over decades? Investing is similar. Knowing past performance helps you understand how various investments act over time.

If you’re torn between index funds and ETFs, their past performance can offer valuable clues. But it’s not just about raw returns — it’s about consistency, costs, and how each fits into your long-term plan.

In this guide, we’ll break down index funds and ETFs. We’ll compare real-world funds and help you make smarter investment choices.

Setting the Stage: What Are We Comparing?

Defining Index Funds

  • Mutual funds that aim to replicate the performance of a specific market index.
  • Typically passive, offering broad diversification at low cost.

Defining ETFs

  • Exchange-Traded Funds that also track indices, sectors, or strategies.
  • Trade like shares, offering intra-day flexibility.

Quick Analogy: Think of an index fund as a set menu at a restaurant — everything’s bundled and served at once. An ETF is like a buffet — similar ingredients but with flexibility on when and how you choose.

Historical Performance: How Do They Stack Up?

1. Returns: Similar, But With a Twist

In recent decades, index funds and ETFs that track the same benchmarks, like the S&P 500 and FTSE 100, have shown nearly the same returns.

Example:

  • The Vanguard S&P 500 Index Fund has been around since 1976, and the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF started in 2010. Both have shown performance differences of only small fractions of a per cent each year.

Why So Similar?

  • Both hold the same underlying assets.
  • Both aim to match, not beat, the benchmark.

2. Costs Create Small Differences

  • ETFs usually have slightly lower expense ratios.
  • However, trading costs and bid-ask spreads can slightly eat into ETF returns for frequent traders.

Morningstar’s studies show that funds with lower costs usually perform better than more expensive ones over time.

3. Reinvestment and Timing

  • Index funds often reinvest dividends automatically.
  • ETFs may require manual reinvestment unless you opt for accumulating versions.

This difference can slightly affect compounding over time if left unmanaged.

Fund Comparison Over Decades: Real-World Examples

The S&P 500 Tracker

Fund Annualised Return (10 years) Expense Ratio Vanguard 500 Index Fund (VFIAX) ~12.2% 0.04% Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO) ~12.2% 0.03%

Key Insight: Returns are nearly identical. A slight cost advantage to ETFs if you avoid trading fees.

The FTSE 100 Tracker (UK Investors)

Fund Annualised Return (10 years) Expense Ratio HSBC FTSE 100 Index Fund ~5.5% 0.06% iShares Core FTSE 100 ETF (ISF) ~5.5% 0.07%

Takeaway: Minimal performance difference. Choice often depends more on how you want to manage your investment.

Important Factors Beyond Returns

1. Liquidity

  • ETFs offer intraday trading, appealing for tactical investors.
  • Index funds only transact once daily at the closing NAV.

2. Investment Minimums

  • Index funds may require a larger initial investment (e.g., £500+).
  • ETFs let you start with the price of one share.

3. Tax Efficiency

  • ETFs are often more tax-efficient due to their in-kind creation and redemption process.
  • Index funds might generate higher capital gains distributions.

Real-World Tip: In ISAs or SIPPs, which are UK tax-advantaged accounts, tax efficiency matters less.

4. Automation

A person holding a glowing gear icon, surrounded by automation-related symbols, with AUTOMATION prominently displayed above.

  • Index funds make it easier to set up regular, automated monthly contributions.
  • ETFs may require manual trading unless your platform supports automatic investments.

Common Misconceptions About Past Performance

1. “Past Returns Guarantee Future Results”

No matter how strong the historical returns, future performance is never assured. Markets evolve, economies shift, and risks emerge.

Golden Rule: Use history as a guide — not a crystal ball.

2. “Higher Fees Mean Higher Returns”

Many assume expensive funds must perform better. The truth? Lower-cost funds often outperform after fees over long periods.

Supporting Evidence: Morningstar’s “Active/Passive Barometer” shows that low-cost passive options often outperform most active funds over time.

Practical Tips for Smart Investing

1. Focus on Long-Term Returns

Short-term fluctuations are noise. Stick to 10-, 20-, or 30-year horizons for evaluating performance.

2. Prioritise Low Fees

A 0.20% fee difference might seem trivial now but compounds to thousands of pounds over decades.

3. Match Your Style

  • Prefer hands-off investing? Index funds might suit you better.
  • Want flexibility and control? ETFs could be your best friend.

4. Diversify Globally

Don’t just focus on one market. Consider global trackers to spread risk across multiple economies.

Example: The Vanguard FTSE Global All Cap Index Fund or the iShares MSCI World ETF offer excellent global exposure.

5. Keep Emotions in Check

A man in formal attire sits at a desk, looking pensively at a computer screen displaying a colorful financial graph, with clouds outside the window.

Markets will rise and fall. Stay calm. Stick to your plan.

Personal Story: In 2020, the markets crashed. Investors who stayed with index funds and ETFs watched their portfolios recover and grow within two years.

A Look in the Rear-View Mirror, A Step Forward

Both index funds and ETFs offer outstanding, low-cost paths to building wealth. Their investment returns have often been nearly the same when following the same indices. The small differences mainly come from costs and trading flexibility.

Choosing between them isn’t just about chasing past performance. It’s about understanding your goals, habits, and comfort with managing investments.

If you love simplicity, automatic investing, and minimal fuss, index funds might be perfect. If you value trading flexibility, lower costs, and hands-on control, ETFs could be your go-to.

Remember: The best investment is the one you stick with through thick and thin.

Ready to build a portfolio with staying power?

Start by choosing the low-cost, long-term option that fits you, and let history guide, not define, your financial journey!

Found this guide helpful? Share it with a fellow investor. Comment on your favourite investment choice. Also, subscribe for more straightforward investing insights!